Search Here!

September 10, 2012

Not All Disney Princesses Are Created Equal-A Guest Post



Ok, let me start with this. Not all princesses are created equal. Now that I've said that, I’d like to also say that I have learned a lot from my childhood princesses (childhood is still going on for me, and will continue until I decide otherwise). 

I realize that many people (ahem, Jenna Marbles) have had a lot of shit to talk about the ladies. 
Disney made you have unrealistic expectations of love? How old were you when you stopped believing a dashing prince would come whisk you away from your horrible parents and marry you because you are the most beautiful girl in town? 

Common sense, y’all. Get some.


Here are a few things I've learned from the changing Disney Princesses through the years. 

Let me start with the ladies who stole our hearts from 1937-1959, The Dreamers.

Snow White: 1937 
I, for one was scared as hell of the evil witch (who was never prettier than SW, seriously Mirror). Aside from that, SW really didn’t have a lot going for her other than her looks, she was extremely handy with a broom however. So yes, I understand that in that time, women were “supposed” to clean up after those silly, dirty men, but as a kid, I learned to whistle while I worked.
Cleaning (and sometimes working) is never fun. But, if you have a good attitude, get some companions to help you and have a good attitude about what you’re doing, the work seems to get done faster. 
Lucifer. aka-Meanest Cat in the World.
Cinderella: 1950
Definitely another example of a damsel in distress, and she’s still doing a lot of housework, but this time Disney doesn’t make her clean up after a man. Cinderella always had a gentle heart, even towards her evil stepsisters and the meanest cat in the world. She may have made a simple wish and wound up in the arms of a handsome stranger, but even after being so badly mistreated she still loved and was extremely grateful for the friends that she did have. 

Sleeping Beauty: 1959 
Ok, this one’s a little harder. Still in the 50’s, Disney is portraying the “perfect” woman as having a gentle heart and great looks. In Sleeping Beauty, Aurora is literally found, gets herself in trouble, rescued and married. So I must turn to the cheeky, courageous fairy godmothers. Their quick thinking and courage helps Prince Philip defeat the evil Maleficent. (Anyone else psyched about the new movie coming out btw??)

Now the ladies from 1989-1992, The Rebels.

The Little Mermaid: 1989 

Thirty years have shaped society’s views of women quite drastically. Finally, we have learned (out loud at least) to fight back and stand up for ourselves. Ariel shows us her adventurous spirit by defying her father and doing what she thinks she ought to be able to do-which of course lands her in a pretty dangerous situation—but Ariel taught me to go after what I wanted and to chase adventure.
You're gonna have to say something interesting to get my head out of this book.
Beauty and the Beast: 1991
Belle did NOT teach me to find a man who has uncontrollable rages and is actually an animal. Belle taught me to enjoy a great book, ignore the taunts of ignorant small-minded folk and to look for true beauty inside a person. Belle didn’t fall in love with Beast because of what he looked like; she loved him because of who he was inside. 

Aladdin: 1992

was the first of the Disney movies that isn’t about a princess, but features a strong female lead. Jasmine was also the first non-white princess after over 50 years of princesses, subtly changing the image of the “ideal woman.” Jasmine was an adventurous spirit, originally with the defiance to marry anybody. Jasmine taught me to pick out what I wanted for my future and to take chances.

Our womanhood has come a long way in 70 years. The Defiant.

Mulan: 1998
This is one of my favorite movies. Unwilling to let her father suffer and die, Mulan (technically not a princess, but worthy of the title) throws herself into danger and risk of death. In the meantime, she saves her man, saves her entire country, and saves her family. Mulan found herself by trying something different, by not reaching out to find love, but by trying to earn respect. Mulan didn’t know what she was capable of until she tried it, and she taught me to go for it, even if the risk is pretty high. 

The Princess and the Frog: 2008
Finally a black princess!! This one is close to my heart because Tiana grew up in New Orleans and can cook! This movie was the first out of many where our princess isn’t looking to find a husband. She knows that hard work is going to cost her a lot and that she’ll need to do a little more than wish to make her dreams come true. Ending up with a handsome, accented prince in the end was just a perk for Tiana, she got everything she wanted by refusing to take no for an answer.
That is not the look of a woman searching for a man.
Brave: 2012
The most recent Disney/Pixar is, in my opinion, the most advanced in female defiance towards a masculine-ruled culture. (SPOILERS AHEAD) Merida doesn’t sing, she doesn’t go to balls or kiss boys. She kicks ass. After Finding Nemo, I really wanted a strong mother-daughter movie that was more than just a tear-jerker. Merida is such a feisty little girl and so defiant of her parent’s wishes that she gets herself and her family into a lot of trouble (surprise). She does, however remedy that problem by acknowledging her mistakes and refusing to quit until she had remedied the problem. My favorite part about this movie was that Merida doesn’t end up with a man at all! She comes up with a creative solution to bind their countrymen together peacefully and shows her prowess for ruling alone.


Looking back, it's pretty incredible how far women have come in the Disney realm of media alone. Generally we have been portrayed as disposable sex objects that need to be cared for. Thankfully, Disney is stepping up to the fact that women are powerful beings and can have a huge impact on the world. I suppose it's up to us to continue the challenge of showing the media that we want powerful heroines. Personally, I can't wait for our first homosexual princess who kicks ass and takes names.



Who is your favorite Disney Princess and Why? Which one influenced you the most? And in terms of the evolving concept of"princesses" where do you think Disney will venture in the future?

(Amanda is a former costume designer turned fast food specialist who is desperately trying to worm her way back to her artistic roots. She lives in Georgia with her husband, her fat cat and their new puppy.)

14 comments:

  1. Man, wouldn't a Drag Princess be amazing?! What a great coming of age story- nerdy boy picked on for being too sweet and soft, and then WHAMMO! Grows up into his own princess who may or may not need a prince to live happily ever after. Now that would push the envelope!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What a fantastic idea!! You should short story that!!

      Delete
  2. I did like Rapunzel in "Tangled." She was sweet, but feisty and was determined to figure out more about herself. And she beat the crap out of Flynn with a frying pan. How domestically kick ass can you get?
    As for your wish for Drag Princesses progression, maybe this will work until it actually happens:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F9ZA7bn5ujk

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That was a-mazinggg!! Thanks for sharing!!

      Delete
    2. I know, isn't it fabulous?!?! Glad you liked it!

      Delete
  3. I always loved Sleeping Beauty as a movie. Not necessarily for Aurora. Not sure how to separate that one. I love Belle. She has an opinion and stands up for herself, but has a soft heart as well. I love that movie.

    I also love Nala from The Lion King. The ultimate partner. Yes, the movie is male centered. But, she does what so many women have to do. Love someone through their hard times. Challenge someone to be their best.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Belle is my favorite. Maybe because I am a bookworm and always felt a little off? Anyway...I also LOVE LOVE LOVE Mulan. The part where everyone bows at the end makes me cry every time. And Peter Jackson TOTALLY ripped it off in The Return of the King.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Cinderella has always been my favorite. I think it has more to do with being my first movie in a theater than the actual movie. However, I do love a good underdog. Time for true confessions...it never occurred to me until I read it in this blog that Aladdin and Jasmine weren't white. How sad it that?!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'm an Aurora fan. I like Sleeping Beauty the best, though The Little Mermaid is a close second. Something about sleeping and having 3 little "godmothers" and a really classy prince. Not to mention...overcoming an evil Maleficent is a little more substantial than overcoming a step-mother. Then again, I've never had a step-mother so who can even know.

    As far as Disney's future...I wonder if they will let their audience or society dictate their changes in their stories. The way Amanda laid this out, it's clear that they have progressed with culture...but how far will the go? I am very interested in that.

    And lastly...I just have to say this in a public place. The Princess and the Frog made me angry. The first black "princess" and the lesson she has to learn is "work harder." That one was hard for me to swallow. Of course it could be said that it fit the times, the economy struggling and all...but I hope there's another black princess in the future who just gets to kick her heels up on her pumpkin carriage and lets her fairy godmother type make all her wishes come true.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think it's a great mention that the movie did come out in 2009, right after economy troubles in '08, but it had been in the making for several years prior. Makes you think for sure. I do like the idea of women "working to get what they want" instead of waiting for someone else to do it. Shows initiative. Do you think there's another lesson in this movie?

      Delete
    2. Great point about the economical implications and timing of the movie. I would have to watch the movie again to take it all in. I'm sure there are more lessons in it! There always are!

      Delete
    3. Totally didn't catch the idea that the first black princess was told to work harder. Although, if I'm looking back at it, that isn't the message of the movie. That's what Tianna thinks she has to do to get her dream. But Mama Odee tells her that's not what she needs- tells her she's blind to what she really needs and can only see what she wants. I agree that I LOVE that this is a princess who makes her dreams happen on her own. She stands up to an evil voodoo man, makes friends with even a lowly bug, saves the day (and the prince) multiple times, and never gives up on her dream. Although, she is still a rescued woman by the end. She marries a prince, and then they live happily ever after. It does show the big white wedding, but she and Naveen do the work on the sugar mill to get it up and running, so I guess that isn't the normal fairy tale.

      I've said a lot, but I'm still not sure what I believe. haha

      Delete
    4. I will admit, I should rewatch it to get the real POINT. But I just know that Aurora's job was to sing in the woods, and Ariel was a hoarder. No working happening there...MAYBE Snow White counts...

      Delete
  7. I have to say the Ariel in the little mermaid has always been my favorite. There's just something about an adventurous red head that I can relate to. I love the princess and the frog too. How can you beat a movie about NOLA and frogs??? Although amber, you make a great point!

    ReplyDelete